Feedback

Who's still buying $160 boxes?

Since the reprint announcement, twenty sealed BP01 booster boxes have sold for $155 or more — one printed $170.99. The $1,800 carton crowd, meanwhile, has all but left the room. One of these groups has it wrong.

Since Bushiroad said the word "reprint," twenty sealed *Dawn of Palpagos* booster boxes have sold for $155 or more. The top print on the tape is $170.99, on Aug 20 — two days after the announcement that was supposed to end the party. Over the same week, the $1,800 carton — the unit that *is* twelve of those boxes — managed nine sales, none of them anywhere near its old price. The whales and the players are now telling two different stories about the same cardboard, and they can't both be right.

Quick rewind if you were outside: on Aug 18 the official account apologized for the shortage and posted the line every sealed holder had been bracing for — "Additional stock is already on the way, and we are currently planning a 2nd Edition print run to ensure more players can get their hands on the game." We logged the pre-news baseline — carton median $1,800, booster box near $160 — and promised to measure what happened next as the sales landed. They've landed.

The carton is where the news bit. Nine completed US sales in the last tracked week, against a 30-day pace of more than eight *a day* — an 84% collapse in velocity. The trailing week's median sits at $1,599.99, down about 11% from $1,797 the week before the news, and not one post-announcement sale has matched the old median. The closest anyone came was $1,699, on Aug 20. Nine sales is a thin read and we'll say so every time; but the direction isn't subtle when the bid simply stops showing up.

Here's the detail I keep staring at. At $1,600, a carton prices its twelve boxes at $133 each. Single boxes are trading at $154. Before the announcement those two numbers sat at rough parity — $150 implied against $155 on the single. The bulk buyer — the one making the biggest single bet on this set's future — now demands a 13% discount to touch it. When conviction leaves a market, it leaves the biggest positions first.

Meanwhile the booster box barely noticed. Ninety-one sales in the same week — a third slower than the 30-day pace, but nothing like frozen — at a $154 median against $155 before the news. A third of post-announcement box sales cleared above the old median. And when supply showed up at actual-retail-adjacent money, it didn't sit: a $130 box restock posted to the restock subreddit on Aug 26 was reported sold out nineteen minutes later. Demand at $130 is instant. Demand at $1,600-a-dozen is a ghost town. That's a standoff, not a crash.

The rest of the sealed board leans the carton's way. Packs slowed to half their 30-day pace, trial decks to a third. Even the JP cartons we flagged as movers on Aug 12 cooled to half speed. Singles sat this one out entirely: the median week-over-week move — across the 86 cards with three-plus sales on both sides of the week — was +0.02%. Whatever this is, it's a sealed-market event — and it's anticipation, not supply. Through Aug 23 our ledger contains exactly zero sales we can attribute to reprint stock, because there isn't any: no date, no quantity, no product. The scene is already asking "Will the 2nd wave crash the market?" and at least one r/PalworldTCG poster is rooting for it — "Hope they reprint this game into the ground." As of today, the entire move is psychological.

Precedent says announcements alone do real work. When Pokémon's *Card 151* got its Japanese reprint in 2024, booster boxes fell from around ¥20,000 to ¥15,000 around the announcement — a quarter of the value gone before the new boxes were even opened. We've watched this movie before, too: Lorcana's *First Chapter* carried a ~$150 MSRP, peaked near $402 in its shortage, and fell back to about $159 once the reprint actually shipped. The pattern: the announcement takes the first bite, shipping product takes the rest, and the size of "the rest" depends on how much of the price was story rather than demand.

What breaks the standoff is a calendar. A dated, sized 2nd Edition forces every holder to price against a known flood; a vague "planned" lets them wait. And the bigger date is already public: BP02 *Legends Awaken* lands Oct 30, and the presale tape says demand hasn't cooled an inch. MSRP-tier preorders at $48–60 are sold out at every hobby shop we checked; the $90–180 markup tier is what's left on the shelf; and the same retailer that took BP01 preorders at $44.99 lists BP02 at $59.99. New supply is nine weeks out. Old supply is "planned." The carton market isn't waiting to find out which one matters; the box market is betting it doesn't have to care.

Base rate, because this desk always hands it over: modern sealed shortage premiums usually give most of it back once real reprint supply ships — usually, not always, and a nine-sale week can wobble in either direction. We'll keep publishing the tape regardless. If you're holding cartons, you either blinked this week or you didn't. The receipts will say which was right.

Sources

Prices mentioned are medians of completed public sales at the time of writing — informational, not financial advice. Cards move; check the live card page before acting on a number.

Verify any number in this post: the methodology · our accuracy audit · corrections.